|
||||||
Views:
9,010,298 |
Main | FAQ | IRC chat | Memberlist | Active users | Latest posts | Stats | Ranks | Online users | Search | 04-24-24 07:51 AM |
||||
Guest: Register | Login |
0 users currently in Craziness Domain 二番: Kuchi Kopi's Bar | 7 bots |
Main - Craziness Domain 二番: Kuchi Kopi's Bar - Review/Rating Scales |
Which review scale do you prefer? | |
5 Stars (1 to 5, no half stars) | |
5 Stars (1 to 5 with half stars) | |
10 Stars | |
A to F (with + and -, like school) | |
61 to 100 | |
0 to 100 | |
Multiple voting is allowed. Changing your vote is allowed. 7 users have voted so far. |
Danielle |
| ||
Normal User
Miracles Happen When you believe... Level: 254 Posts: 1142/25311 EXP: 264041979 Next: 741346 Since: 07-16-12 From: Albany, NY OS: Windows 98 Last post: 145 days Last view: 145 days |
With all of the product/book/music/etc. review websites out there, which scale do you think is best?
- 5 stars with no half stars: Probably the most common, I like this one because it's simple - 5 stars with half stars: Really? if you're going to do this, why not... - 10 stars: Eh, it's OK I suppose... not very common however - A to F like school grades: I like this system too, I remember one of the gaming magazines being fond of this - 61 to 100: why? what makes an 86 so different from an 87? It seems silly in a music or product review - 0 to 100: even worse than the preceding Overall, I prefer the 5 stars without half stars as well as the A to F grade system for reviews "Miracles happen, when you believe..."
YouTube |
Epele |
| ||
Site Administrator
The Sorceress. Boing~ Level: 235 Posts: 12100/20774 EXP: 200776675 Next: 1149217 Since: 01-01-12 From: UK Last post: 840 days Last view: 20 hours |
I'm ok with the 5 stars, as long as it isn't on the 10-point system with "half stars" except when adding review scores together to get an average.
Otherwise, I really like the letter graded system. It's a good system. The world could always use more heroes! |
Nicole |
| ||
Administrator
Goddess of the Apocalypse Level: 199 Posts: 7358/14042 EXP: 111552000 Next: 1585084 Since: 01-03-12 From: Boston, MA Last post: 256 days Last view: 255 days |
♥7358 ✿4494 ★19 I honestly don't like review scales... I read reviews for the reviewers experience, since people's opinions on video games so rarely agree perfectly with mine I need specifics. |
Squiddy |
| ||
Banned
Unspecificed Cooling Off Period. Be Safe Bisexual Empress of the Stolen Title? Level: 142 Posts: 2790/6751 EXP: 34791905 Next: 176524 Since: 07-17-13 Last post: 3206 days Last view: 3113 days |
Where's the "This is good/This is bad" option? D: I'm sorta like Nicole on this matter. ____________________ Sunshine Realm Welcome to Aqmlm's, the only board with Al-Aq'mlmistrators! |
Phyresis |
| ||
Normal User
1490?! Level: 41 Posts: 84/392 EXP: 466001 Next: 14144 Since: 06-11-14 Last post: 3107 days Last view: 3093 days |
Rating scales just serve to lead readers to not read the body of the review and instead make a conclusion based on an arbitrary number only. They all suck to some extent or another. |
Kak |
| ||
Global Moderator
Bullet Bill well then Level: 129 Posts: 3975/5515 EXP: 25038856 Next: 10798 Since: 01-29-14 From: ??? Last post: 835 days Last view: 781 days |
I have a (0 to 5) rating that is similar to the rating system of Xkeeper/Tyty:
Here's my potentially NWS rating system. |
skyl |
| ||
Normal User
I guess I pop up occasionally now Level: 103 Posts: 957/3207 EXP: 11243625 Next: 227781 Since: 10-26-13 Last post: 231 days Last view: 223 days |
I prefer 1 to 5 with half stars. (sometimes one is too high and the other is too low, half stars are necessary) ____________________ Can you burn a Luigi board? |
Taryn |
| |||
Normal User
Red Birdo RIP Fat Lesbian Level: 88 Posts: 1933/2142 EXP: 6579013 Next: 71651 Since: 04-03-12 From: Seattle, USA Last post: 3454 days Last view: 3453 days |
|
Squiddy |
| ||
Banned
Unspecificed Cooling Off Period. Be Safe Bisexual Empress of the Stolen Title? Level: 142 Posts: 3081/6751 EXP: 34791905 Next: 176524 Since: 07-17-13 Last post: 3206 days Last view: 3113 days |
Posted by Taryn I think I have seen negative numbers before. They were for things that are beyond horrible, I think. ____________________ Sunshine Realm Welcome to Aqmlm's, the only board with Al-Aq'mlmistrators! |
skyl |
| ||
Normal User
I guess I pop up occasionally now Level: 103 Posts: 1029/3207 EXP: 11243625 Next: 227781 Since: 10-26-13 Last post: 231 days Last view: 223 days |
Posted by SquidEmpressPosted by Taryn Only -1 should be used. It should be treated like a black hole: -1 is basically negative-infinity, the lowest rating possible. ____________________ Can you burn a Luigi board? |
Main - Craziness Domain 二番: Kuchi Kopi's Bar - Review/Rating Scales |
Acmlmboard v2.5.5 (10/04/2020) © 2005-2024 Acmlm, Emuz, et al. |
MySQL - queries: 128, rows: 578/613, time: 0.117 seconds. |